Here's an extract from a recent Telegraph.co.uk article called Australian town, 326 miles from river, hit by raining fish. Check out the quote from Joe Ashley, 55:
Harry Campbell sent this one in to The Engine Room, and he asks: "Is punctuation now rationed at the Daily Telegraph?"
If anything, I think the lack of punctuation conveys a rather appropriate sense of panic on the part of Joe Ashley. I'd be panicked if I thought crocodiles might start dropping out of the sky...
Usually fish are in the water now they are falling out of the sky
Posted by
JD (The Engine Room)
on Thursday, 11 March 2010
Labels:
punctuation,
subbing,
The Telegraph
6 comments:
They spoiled the stream-of-consciousness effect a bit with the tabloid-style unnecessary para break and paradoxically-scrupulous use of quotation marks. Perhaps they shd have gone the whole hog with something like "Itcouldbecrocodilesthatwouldberealscaryomigodwhasthatupthererunrunforyourlivesboys!!!!"
Perhaps "Joe Ashley" is a pseudonym for Gertrude Stein?
What? It's a perfectly well-formed sentence with a restrictive clause in the conditional, to match the main clause. Scary crocodiles could fall from the sky! Really scary ones!
Do you suppose that was lifted straight from a text or e-mail? And maybe they don't want to edit, even if that helps it make sense?
TootsNYC - that crossed my mind too. But there's also a comma missing after 'Jabiru' so I think it's just an editorial lapse.
Harry - I agree with you!
This is brilliant — it lends a breathless sense of urgency and near-hysteria to the report. More news stories should use stream-of-consciousness quotes.
Post a Comment